Wandering China

An East/West pulse of China's fourth rise from down under.

China holds closing ceremony for Shanghai Expo [China Daily/Xinhua]

Sunday marked the end of the Shanghai Expo, and I had the chance to watch some of it on TV. More money was spent on the Expo than the Olympic Games, and the media representation was top notch. I have heard much internal criticisms about how it reeks of elitism and favoritism (especially from popular Chinese blogger Han Han) toward the rich and powerful, but having being part of the everyday Chinese flock to visit the Expo and what it had to offer – I can bear testimony that many ordinary Chinese minds were emancipated as a result. Beyond them benefitting from China’s economic progress, this expo would also have alleviated their minds in giving them an opportunity to them see, appreciate, and learn how to work with the wider world; that there is a larger picture outside the great wall.

There is always a give and take element to events of such magnitude, and perhaps the net gain should be the focus. I am sure more bridges were built than broken. It is a tantamount task to please 73 million visitors. The first Expo to be held in a ‘developing’ country (China continues to play this card close to the chest),  I guess it was no surprise a PR spiel such as this – ‘The gala is eyed in China as another event of national splendor after the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games showcased China’s status as an economic and political power to the world’ was reinforced. China’s charm offensive and public diplomacy would have most certainly gained another powerful agent with this event.

– – –

China holds closing ceremony for Shanghai Expo
Source – China Daily, published October 31, 2010

Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao (3rd R) attends the closing ceremony of the Shanghai World Expo at the Expo Cultural Center in the World Expo Park in Shanghai, Oct 31, 2010. Photo - Xinhua

SHANGHAI – The 184-day Shanghai World Expo came to the end as a closing ceremony started here Sunday evening.

Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao and other dignitaries attended the ceremony.

Chinese Vice Premier Wang Qishan said the Expo has made China and the world come closer together, and a more open, inclusive and culturally advanced China that steadily moves forward will join other countries in the world to usher in an ever brighter future for all.

He said the Expo spirit will be carried forward from generation to generation. Read the rest of this entry »

Filed under: Beijing Consensus, Charm Offensive, China Daily, Communications, Culture, Education, Han Han, Influence, International Relations, Media, Nationalism, Politics, Public Diplomacy, Shanghai World Expo, Social, Soft Power, Strategy, The Chinese Identity, The construction of Chinese and Non-Chinese identities

Novelist Han Han:A City Built on a Heap of Money Won’t Shine [Commonwealth Magazine, Taiwan]

The writer Han Han prides himself as a truth seeker – and he writes refreshingly boldly for a ‘subject’ of communist China. The article claims understanding the likes of Han Han is critical to understanding “complex zeitgeist and its future”, and my dad thinks so too. 300 million visits to his blog since 2006 will yield some idea of the mindshare he commands.

“Having crisscrossed China on his car racing assignments, Han has seen China’s real face outside the affluent metropolitan areas of Beijing and Shanghai. On these trips he has seen poor workers, witnessed how people choose to remain silent about injustices in order to make a living. He has also noticed that a sense of inferiority lurks behind ostensive national confidence and pride.”

For more on Han Han, check out previous post (Feb 2010) – Han Han’s Speech At Xiamen University: “The So-called Grand Cultural Nation”

– – –

Novelist Han Han:A City Built on a Heap of Money Won’t Shine
By Sherry Lee and Shu-ren Koo
Source – CommonWealth Magazine, published April 01, 2010 (No.443)

Racing champion, novelist, blogger and all-round fly in the ointment of Chinese officialdom, Han Han argues that the future of Shanghai lies, not in its World Expo, but in greater freedom of expression. Photo - Commonwealth Magazine

If you don’t know China’s literary rebel Han Han and the “Han Han phenomenon” that he unleashed, then it will be hard for you to grasp China’s complex zeitgeist and its future.

Born in Shanghai in 1982, the 27-year-old is the star writer of China’s new generation.

Han’s first novel Triple Door, published in 2000, has so far sold more than two million copies. His blog is believed to be the most widely read worldwide with well over 300 million visits since it was launched in 2006. Han also doubles as a professional racecar driver – among other achievements, he was Group N winner of the 2009 China Rally Championship. That same year Hong Kong-based Asia Weekly voted him Person of the Year, and Time magazine interviewed him for an article titled “China’s Literary Bad Boy.” And Han Han accomplished all of this after dropping out of high school as a freshman.

A racecar-driving author with handsome looks and a sharp, dispassionate writing style, Han Han’s trademark blend of complexity and radicalism gives his works considerable literary power.

Han prides himself on seeking the truth. This urge to speak his mind has helped him to maintain a capacity of independent thinking in the group-oriented society of China.

Having crisscrossed China on his car racing assignments, Han has seen China’s real face outside the affluent metropolitan areas of Beijing and Shanghai. On these trips he has seen poor workers, witnessed how people choose to remain silent about injustices in order to make a living. He has also noticed that a sense of inferiority lurks behind ostensive national confidence and pride.

Han tries to record the truth. Among the issues that have drawn his attention are issues of everyday life such as the forced demolition of private houses by the government, but Han also voices his views on where China should be headed in the future.

“China might have a Constitution, but that’s just bullshit. Nobody respects it at all. Everyone is trampling on it,” Han said in an exclusive interview with CommonWealth Magazine. In China such provocative language would most likely be deleted by censors.

Han Han has been pushing the envelope of freedom of expression in China. In order to gain maximum freedom in his work, he chose to become his own boss, setting up his own office. Thanks to the proceeds from his books and the cash awards and endorsement proceeds from his racing career, Han has been able to create his own literary space where he can breathe freely.

While Han Han is not optimistic about the future development of Shanghai or China at large, his emergence as a celebrity writer also shows that there is an opportunity for change in China.

How does Han Han feel about his own influence, and what are his views about Shanghai and the World Expo that will open there in May?

I was born in 1982. Actually the entire generation born after 1980 can be considered independent thinkers. China has never been short of independent thinkers.

I write stuff online purely because it’s somewhat less censored. Many say that freedom of expression has made great strides in recent years, but this progress was triggered by technology. It’s not that the authorities wanted to make changes – they were forced to do so. Nevertheless, it’s a good thing that there has been some progress. That’s why I hope there will be even better technologies in the future, so that it will become impossible to block anything.

Many people say that Shanghai is more cultured than Hong Kong! Right around the founding of the People’s Republic of China (in 1949), many plays, movies and literary works came from Shanghai. Back then Shanghai truly was a cultural center. But I don’t know why Shanghai developed into what it is today. Probably it’s because Shanghai is nothing but a springboard for many officials who want to get into the central government. They think that if they are able to manage Shanghai well, they will be able to manage China well. As a result, once they come to Shanghai, officials or leaders do their jobs very, very cautiously. The newspapers in Shanghai, for instance, have very, very, very tight controls.

In reality, it’s already been proven that with such a strict controls and such a stressful living environment, it’s not possible to create outstanding literature or art.

If you asked me which big Chinese city is a cultural desert, then I’d say Shanghai. One hundred percent, it’s Shanghai. In comparison, culture suffers less destruction in Hong Kong and Taiwan. It’s in these two places that Chinese culture lives on.

Today’s Shanghai doesn’t have culture. The city was built with a heap of money, and then they pushed up the housing prices sky-high. If I was the mayor of Shanghai, I would feel very embarrassed. I would ask people to stay away for the time being, and come back after I got something done. Present-day Shanghai actually doesn’t have anything to be proud of.

Shanghai has nothing to show off. It doesn’t have any film directors or writers or artists. There’s not a lot to this city.

When it comes to the World Expo, I don’t like it at all.

The Expo may be well organized or successful. But whether it’s the Beijing Olympics or the World Expo, during the event period any article you write containing negative or questioning remarks will be immediately deleted. Such a city doesn’t qualify as an international metropolis.

Looking at Shanghai from a cultural angle, when American dramas are hot, everyone watches American dramas, and when Korean dramas are hot, they watch Korean ones. A while ago Japanese dramas were hot, so people watched them. Then Taiwanese variety shows were popular, so that’s what people watched. We will eternally be copying others. Sometimes even our cloned products are not good copies.

It’s definitely not that the people here lack ability, it’s just that they don’t have enough room. They want to have more breathing space, but that’s what the government is afraid of. There’s a contradiction between the two. It’s the same for myself. I hope to be given more generous standards, so that I can breathe more easily.

My only hope is that this country will be able to achieve something that we can truly show off. Otherwise, when I tell people about my country, and they ask, “What films has your country produced? What literature?” all I’ll be able to come up with is Confucius. That’s really boring. At the moment, I’m only experimenting, trying things out.

Foreigners look at us the same way we look at Shanxi coal barons. In other words, they don’t respect you, but now that you have money, who wouldn’t go make some money off you?

I only hope that speech and newspapers in China can become freer, and more open. My motivation is simple – only if this is the case can I criticize other countries and export my own culture. If this is not the case, there’s no way we could export our own culture, since what could you talk about with other countries?

Only if we have culture can everyone feel great national pride. When everyone feels proud of their own assets, their own cultural assets, then this city will be truly good.

What I can do in our current society is write even more articles to change society with more cultural things. I don’t have as huge an influence as people say. I’m just a writer. If change is really going to take place, then it would probably require me multiplied by a hundred.

The problem is that only people within a certain circle can read my articles, but it’s still not easy to expand readership beyond that circle. Outside, migrant workers still go about their lives as before, the female textile workers still do their jobs. They read the party paper and watch TV news broadcasts just like always.

Translated from the Chinese by Susanne Ganz

Han Han

Born in 1982
Current Positions: Professional racecar driver, author, editor
Education: Dropped out of Shanghai Songjiang No. 2 Senior High School
Literary Works:
14 books including novels such as Triple Door and essay collections. Triple Door sold two million copies, making it the bestselling literary work in China in the past two decades.
Musical Works: Lyrics for his debut album Han 18-R released in 2006
Magazine: Literary magazine Chorus of Solos, whose publication is still under negotiation with the Chinese authorities.

Filed under: Censorship, Culture, Han Han, Human Rights, Internet, Nationalism

Han Han’s Speech At Xiamen University: “The So-called Grand Cultural Nation”

An insight into what some of the more free-spirited Chinese think of their nation from the inside. In a sense, I agree that the powers that be try to control the culture. But like sand, the more and harder one tries to grasp it, the more it will slip away. With certain things, the Chinese have to learn how to be like the water. But certainly, water travels over time too. Open the floodgates carelessly and letting it gush too early – who knows what will happen?

– – –

Han Han’s Speech At Xiamen University: “The So-called Grand Cultural Nation”
Source – China Digital Times, 04 Feb 2010

Han Han. Source - China Digital Times

Author, race-car driver and blogger ’s most recent speech at Xiamen University, translated on the EastSouthWestNorth blog:

This is my second time in Xiamen. The weather here is great. No wonder people like to go outside and stroll. Hmmm … I just heard Teacher Deng spoke about certain issues on nationalism. I was reminded of a couple of sayings which I came across them previously. They are other people’s words, not mine. The first saying is, “Nationalism is the last refuge of scoundrels.” The second saying is, “True patriotism is to protect this country so that it will not suffer any harm.”

For today’s talk, I have brought along a written speech in order to constrain myself. Mainly, I don’t want you to suffer any harm because I may stray all over the place. Let me begin.

Dear leaders, dear teachers, dear students, how are you doing?

Do you know why China cannot become a grand cultural nation? It is because most of the time when we speak, we say “Dear leaders” first and those leaders are uncultured. Not only that, for they are also afraid of culture, they censor culture and they control culture. So how can such a nation become a grand cultural nation? Dear leaders, what do you say?

Actually, China has tremendous potential of becoming a grand cultural nation. Let me tell you a story. I am the chief editor of a magazine which has yet to publish. The Constitution states that every citizen has the freedom to publish, but the law also says that the leaders has the freedom not to let you publish. This magazine has run into some problems during the review process. There is a cartoon drawing. In it, there is a man without clothes — of course, this is unacceptable because the law says that we cannot exhibit the private parts in a publicly available magazine. I agree with that and I don’t have a problem with it. Therefore, I intentionally created an extra-large magazine logo that was placed over the illegal spot of the cartoon. But unexpectedly, the publisher and the censor told us that this was unacceptable too — when you cover up the middle part of a person, you are referring to the “Party Central” (note: “party” is a homonym for “block/shield” and “central” is “middle”). My reaction was like yours — I was awed and shocked. I thought to myself, “Buddy, it would be so wonderful if you could put your awe-inspiring imagination into literary creation instead of literary censorship!”

Filed under: Censorship, China Digital Times, Culture, Han Han, Human Rights, Nationalism

Follow me on Twitter



July 2020

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 2,242 other followers

East/West headlines of Rising China

East/West headlines of Rising China

About Wandering China

Click to find out more about this project

Support //WC

Support Wandering China now - buy a Tee Shirt!

Be a champ - Support Wandering China - buy a Tee Shirt!

The East Wind Wave

China in images and infographics, by Wandering China

China in images and Infographics, by Wandering China

Wandering China: Facing west

Please click to access video

Travels in China's northwest and southwest

Wandering Taiwan

Wandering Taiwan: reflections of my travels in the democratic Republic of China

Wandering China, Resounding Deng Slideshow

Click here to view the Wandering China, Resounding Deng Slideshow

Slideshow reflection on Deng Xiaoping's UN General Assembly speech in 1974. Based on photos of my travels in China 2011.

East Asia Geographic Timelapse

Click here to view the East Asia Geographic Timelapse

A collaboration with my brother: Comparing East Asia's rural and urban landscapes through time-lapse photography.

Wandering Planets

Creative Commons License
Wandering China by Bob Tan is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Based on a work at Wanderingchina.org. Thank you for visiting //
web stats

Flag Counter

free counters
Online Marketing
Add blog to our directory.