Wandering China

An East/West pulse of China's fourth rise from down under.

Does China Have a Soul? [The Diplomat]

From Tokyo-based online current affairs magazine ‘The Diplomat’: Under its China Power: A New World Order section, it poses the question ‘Does China Have a Soul? Here are two interesting comments from readers of the article.

Henry003 February 5, 2012 at 3:33 pm
The western press has been predicting the demise of PRC since the founding of PRC but it never materialized. For the simple fact that for most Chinese live are getting better with every day and only small segment of population known known as dissident would like to follow the west. The majority of the people couldn’t care less. I can never understand why people still beating the dead horse over and over again

Spartan February 5, 2012 at 10:11 am
Whenever someone says that China has a 4000 year history I cringe because the Communist Party did a pretty good job at destroying the previous zeitgeist. Sometimes when taking a taxi in DongBei I’ll run into a driver who wants to talk down to me as the “young American” and tell me that his country has a 4000 year history. Unfortunately, China in many respects resembles a narcissist who was beaten as a child and has to talk itself up to maintain a working degree of self esteem.

While I agree the search for a unifying spirit holds water as the author makes a salient point –

This question must sound embarrassingly racist or, given China’s economic trajectory, increasingly irrelevant. But it’s also China’s most important question because the flip side of this question is: Does China have a future?

I must add that pro-China commentators can tend to harp on the continuity of the Chinese civilisation while the dichotomy also sees the cultural revolution as evidence of its current ‘hypocrisy’ of having Confucius Institutes as a public diplomacy and internal social glue to extend/maintain China’s cultural capital.

Sometimes polarity means neglecting to see the forest for the trees.

The geo-political and territorial institution that is China has never been singular, nor smooth.

Chinese-ness on the other hand, as an identity has not only survived, but seems to have been reinforced (through assimilation or otherwise) all this time.

Witness the dynastic and political strife the China has had to bear to get to where it is today. China was divided for long periods of its history, with different regions being ruled by different groups and for a third of recorded history, by foreign rulers. For about another third of it, it was arguable if there a any single dynasty ruling a unified China.

Perhaps tongue-in-cheek, my take on the argument that China does not have a soul will hold water, the day the Chinese stop using chopsticks.

– – –

Does China Have a Soul?
By Jiang Xueqin
Source – The Diplomat, published Feb 5, 2012

The New York Review of Books blog has posted an Ian Johnson interview with Zhang Ping (who writes under the name Chang Ping), one of China’s most daring writers whom the Communist Party previously hounded out of reporting from China.

The piece is worth reading for both the interviewee and the interviewer.

Inspired by Liu Binyan to become a journalist, Chang Ping has a career that shares many similarities with that of his role model. But there’s one major difference. Liu, with his journalistic exposes of the inept Communist Party political, economic, social, and moral management of China, inspired a generation of disaffected youth to carry the intellectual flame.

By the late 1990s, when Chang Ping came into prominence at Southern Weekend, a Guangzhou-based newspaper famed for its investigative journalism, the Party had begun to buy out China’s intellectual class so successfully that it could easily persecute those who couldn’t be bought out – individuals such as He Qinglian, Ai Weiwei, and Chang Ping.

Chang Ping now lives in Germany, but is attempting to start a new media organization to effect change in China.  Unfortunately, as was the case with Liu and He, Chinese intellectuals tend to fade away once in exile.

For China watchers, Johnson needs no introduction, as he’s the most intellectual of Western reporters working in China today.  In much of his recent reporting, Johnson spends a lot of time sipping tea with exiled Chinese writers or meditating with Daoist masters. And I think he does so because he seeks enlightenment on a question that must gnaw at all China watchers: Does China have a soul?

This question must sound embarrassingly racist or, given China’s economic trajectory, increasingly irrelevant. But it’s also China’s most important question because the flip side of this question is: Does China have a future?

We are often blind to these questions because we are so focused on economic data, which we faithfully believe to reveal the reality of China to us. But GDP growth, consumer spending, and stock market ups and downs don’t tell us the level of individual happiness or the strength of social cohesion. Economic data may tell us that China is more prosperous and powerful today than at any time in its history, and that’s true. But what’s also true, if you crisscross China talking to elderly Chinese, is that China was more honest and happy back in the Mao Zedong days than it is today.

It’s obvious from his reporting that Johnson would rather trust his own eyes than economic data. He’s interested in China’s intellectual and spiritual state – or what Chang Ping calls “the civic spirit” – because that’s what reveals a nation’s “emotional intelligence,” China’s ability to absorb the shock of the inevitable economic downturn, and China’s will to hold together when the economic glue fades.

The United States is facing a tough economic storm now, but no one doubts that the American people share “civic spirit” and are all invested in the nation’s democratic soul, as is so eloquently outlined in Jefferson’s “Declaration of Independence” and Abraham Lincoln’s speeches. And that’s why most can be confident that this current recession will only make America leaner and stronger in the end.

On the other hand, the European Union has no unifying ideas and values, and that’s why the possibility of a Greek default, no matter its impact economically, could begin the process of the EU’s political death.

Within the Party’s inner sanctums, the nation’s soul is very much a concern.  Consider President Hu Jintao’s speech calling for China to expand its cultural power both abroad and at home: The Communist Party is desperate for a unifying vision to unite the Chinese people for the economic tough times ahead.

Ironically, a nation’s soul and cultural unity comes from the same poets and philosophers, its thinkers and writers (individuals such as Liu, He, Ai Weiwei, and Chang Ping) that the Communist Party has persecuted. The United States soft power – its vision of individual freedom and empowerment that animates both Disney movies and Special Forces troops operating in the world’s most far-flung corners – developed its power and force through generations of open and honest and vigorous debate over its soul.

Does China have a soul?  We’ll only know once the China edifice starts crumbling. If it doesn’t have a soul, then China may very well fall into the abyss. If it does, whether it be a previously hidden intellectual or religious tradition, it will naturally rise to the challenge.

Johnson is now scouring China for what could save the Communist Party, or what could possibly come after the Party and ultimately save China. And that’s why his reporting, while neither trendy nor topical, is certainly urgent and necessary.


Filed under: Beijing Consensus, Chinese Model, Confucius, Culture, Democracy, Domestic Growth, Economics, Education, Influence, Lifestyle, Mapping Feelings, Modernisation, Nationalism, Peaceful Development, People, Politics, Public Diplomacy, Reform, Social, The Chinese Identity, The construction of Chinese and Non-Chinese identities

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 2,575 other followers

East/West headlines of Rising China

East/West headlines of Rising China

About Wandering China

Click to find out more about this project

Support //WC

Support Wandering China now - buy a Tee Shirt!

Be a champ - Support Wandering China - buy a Tee Shirt!

The East Wind Wave

China in images and infographics, by Wandering China

China in images and Infographics, by Wandering China

Wandering China: Facing west

Please click to access video

Travels in China's northwest and southwest

Wandering Taiwan

Wandering Taiwan: reflections of my travels in the democratic Republic of China

Wandering China, Resounding Deng Slideshow

Click here to view the Wandering China, Resounding Deng Slideshow

Slideshow reflection on Deng Xiaoping's UN General Assembly speech in 1974. Based on photos of my travels in China 2011.

East Asia Geographic Timelapse

Click here to view the East Asia Geographic Timelapse

A collaboration with my brother: Comparing East Asia's rural and urban landscapes through time-lapse photography.

Wandering Planets

Creative Commons License
Wandering China by Bob Tan is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Based on a work at Wanderingchina.org. Thank you for visiting //
web stats

Flag Counter

free counters
Online Marketing
Add blog to our directory.
%d bloggers like this: